All of Scioteca
Communities & Collections By Issue Date Authors Titles Subjects Country / Region
Profiles
Our Authors
My Account
Login

Difference-in-Differences in Equilibrium: Evidence from Placed-Based Policies

Violations of the stable unit treatment value assumption (SUTVA) are a common threat to identification of the effects of policies causing the resorting of agents between treated and untreated groups. We show that in such contexts the difference-in-differences estimator can be decomposed into three effects (autarky, resorting and contamination). We also show that demand and supply elasticities are “sufficient statistics” for the relative size of these effects and that there exist a trade-off in terms of heterogeneity between SUTVA and parallel trends assumption violations. We illustrate our argument by studying a large placed-based tax break for the construction of residential housing in Uruguay. First, we obtain a series of difference-in-differences estimates of the effect of the policy on housing prices and show that they differ considerably depending on the degree of heterogeneity between subsidized and unsubsidized areas. Consistent with our conceptual framework, prices fall substantially when comparing heterogeneous areas, and very little or not at all when comparing similar areas. Second, we estimate a structural model of supply and demand for neighborhoods that rationalizes those different estimates and allows us to recover the three effects as well as the welfare impact of the policy. Overall, we find that SUTVA violations account for 25% of the effect on subsidized areas and lead to a sizable underestimation (24 p.p.) of the incidence of the tax break on subsidized areas.

Abstract

Description

Subject

Banca de desarrollo | Infraestructura | Vivienda

País / Región

América Latina y el Caribe

URI

https://scioteca.caf.com/handle/123456789/2192

Date

2023-12-26

Cite from this publication

Collections

6.1 Documentos de trabajo en investigación socioeconómica

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By

Creative Commons license

CC-BY-NC-ND
Except where otherwised noted, this item's license is described as CC-BY-NC-ND
Thumbnail Image

Files

Dif in Dif in equilibrium_evidence from place-based policies_Alves_Burton_Fleitas.pdf (1008.71 KB)

Authors

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

CAF- banco de desarrollo de América Latina y el Caribe

Related Items

Thumbnail Image
Are Taxes Credits Effective in Developing Countries? The Recent Uruguayan Experience

Investment promotion through tax incentives has been a key component of the growth strategies pursued in Uruguay by the last three administrations. A new regime...

Thumbnail Image
Income Segregation and Urban Spatial Structure: Evidence from Brazil

We estimate the effect of urban spatial structure on income segregation in Brazilian cities between 2000 and 2010. Our results show that, first, local density...

Thumbnail Image
Motherhood and the Allocation of Talent

In this paper we show that motherhood triggers changes in the allocation of talent in the labor market beyond the well-known effects on gender gaps...

Thumbnail Image
Spillovers of health education at school on parents´ physical activity

To prevent modern health conditions like obesity, cancer, cardiovascular illness, and diabetes, which have reached epidemic-like proportions in recent decades, many health experts argue that...

Thumbnail Image
A Taxonomy of Colombia’s Informal Labor Market

A taxonomy of the informal labor market is extremely important to understand and handle informality, particularly in a country as Colombia where this phenomenon is...

Thumbnail Image
Slum Growth in Brazilian Cities

I study slum growth in contemporary urbanization processes by estimating a spatial equilibrium model with houses with and without basic water and sanitation services in...