All of Scioteca
Communities & Collections By Issue Date Authors Titles Subjects Country / Region
Profiles
Our Authors
My Account
Login

Inter-jurisdictional coordination in the management of natural resources: evidence from water basin committees in Brazil

Decentralized management of public goods creates the potential for spillovers across jurisdictions. These spillovers may be particularly large in the case of river management where the river has little value to upstream constituents once it has left the jurisdiction. Cross border cooperation in management of public goods can reduce spillovers, but negotiation between jurisdictions can be difficult to achieve. This paper estimates the effectiveness of policy interventions designed to increase the potential for coordination and negotiation between jurisdictions and investigates the mechanisms through which water management committees and other forums designed to enable cooperation between jurisdictions may improve cross border cooperation. We develop a simple theoretical model, based on a two stage bargaining game, in which we analyze negotiation between jurisdictions. We arrive at several key theoretical predictions: 1) Pollution levels between jurisdictions decrease following the institution of water basin committees, 2) These reductions in pollution loads are largest in the downstream areas of the river, and 3) Political affiliation and other factors which reduce transactions costs between counties also lead to larger negotiated pollution reductions by the upstream county. We find that overall; water basin management committees have a mixed impact on water quality. Organic pollution loads appear to decrease with the institution of water basin committees, but the overall health of the river as measured by dissolved oxygen content appears to be relatively unaffected by the institution of water basin committees. Consistent with the model, we find that the impact of water basin committees is largest in the downstream portion of the river where information asymmetries about the origin of the pollution are largest. We also find that increases in political cohesion between the upstream and downstream counties lead to decreases in organic pollution loads between the upstream and downstream counties. These decreases in pollution arising from decreased costs of negotiation between local leaders appear to be largest when combined with dedicated forums for negotiation between the counties.

Abstract

Description

Subject

Agua y saneamiento | Ambiente | Investigación socioeconómica | Recursos naturales | Gobernabilidad

País / Región

Brasil

URI

https://scioteca.caf.com/handle/123456789/196

Date

2009

Cite from this publication

Collections

6.1 Documentos de trabajo en investigación socioeconómica

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By

Creative Commons license

CC-BY-NC
Except where otherwised noted, this item's license is described as CC-BY-NC
Thumbnail Image

Files

200903LipscombyMobarak.pdf (377.96 KB)

Authors

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

CAF

Related Items

Thumbnail Image
Getting to know the Amazon - Path of Orellana

Over six thousand kilometers travelled by air, land and water, most of it on the main course of the Amazon River; going deep into the...

Thumbnail Image
Development effects of electrification: evidence from the geologic placement of hydropower plants in Brazil

We estimate the development effects of electrification across Brazil over the period 1960-2000. Brazil relies almost exclusively on hydropower, which requires intercepting water at high...

Thumbnail Image
Water Security in Barbados and 11 countries of the Eastern Caribbean

Caribbean countries are highly vulnerable to natural disasters. Extreme weather events are common, the region experienced three Category 5 hurricanes between 2017 and 2019. When...

Thumbnail Image
Characterizing Fuel Choices and Fuelwood Use for Residential Heating and Cooking in Urban Areas of Central-Southern Chile: the Role of Prices, Income, and the Availability of Energy Sources and Technology

This paper analyzes empirically the determinants of fuel choices and intensity of fuelwood use for residential heating and cooking in central-southern Chile. By using information...

Thumbnail Image
Women’s representation and the governance of the commons

The study analyzes how the inclusion of women in community governance bodies affects the management of common resources. It takes advantage of the 2016 reform...

Thumbnail Image
Political Alignment and Inter-jurisdictional Cooperation in a Fragmented Political Landscape: Evidence from Mexico

We investigate the relationship between neighboring municipal authorities’ shared party affiliation and inter-jurisdictional cooperation agreements in Mexico. Exploiting a Regression Discontinuity Design in close municipal...